OCD-DRU Patrick Forbes accuses flood victim "..creating unnecessary panic and frustration among flood victims"


By Murray Wennerlund published 12-16-2018 updated 6-5-2019
Contribute $3.00 | Download PDF | Print | Tag: FloodInsurance

My neighbor came over banging on our door asking for me to read the 30 day notice to purchase flood insurance to cover the Programs costs or be deemed ineligible for HUD CDBG-DR Grants. This comes weeks and months after grants were awarded and signed.

Pat Forbes <Patrick.Forbes@LA.GOV>
Fri 11/16/2018, 3:00 PM
Mr. Wennerlund,

I wanted to promptly reply to your recent blog post and once again request, as we have offered in the past, to meet with you to discuss your comments and concerns as they relate to the Restore Louisiana Homeowner Assistance Program. It appears we both have the same intentions in mind to provide funds to eligible homeowners so they can recover from the devastating floods of 2016.

And while I trust that you are trying to be helpful to those who read your posts and follow you on social media, in fact you are often providing completely incorrect information and statements not based in current law or policy, which is only creating unnecessary panic and frustration among flood victims.

We certainly recognize and agree that these programs can be incredibly complicated and frustrating and also that there is always room for us to improve and streamline our processes to better help people recover from the flood.

We would like to work with you to help you better understand the issues on which you're commenting and hope to hear from you soon.


Pat Forbes

<<< END EMAIL >>>

Editorial, Comments and Updates: 

The OCD-DRU director Patrick Forbes did not respond to posts about the state giving only 30 days to low and moderate income families that had purchased FEMA NFIP Group flood insurance. The state gave flood victims from low income to retirees 30 days to provide proof of NFIP coverage to match program costs. This was the same as telling a low income fixed income retiree to come up with $250 or more to purchase a new NFIP Insurance policy. Sorry Mr. Forbes, this isn't something fixed income households can do without adding serious financial stress on the household. And to demand it the first 2 weeks of December may have been just a little insensitive, unless you were worried about your 4th quarter reports to HUD and the mistakes your Program hires made. 

Slipped under the radar! This one line policy change in the Restore Louisiana Homeowner Program Manual version 4.0 was within the scope of work by the Program, but was it timed to correct the states HUD 4th quarter final reports or was it an attempt to reduce the number of active applicants and leave homeowners in a difficult spot just before the holidays?

The Program did not send a notice out which would have alerted many homeowners of the updated and new insurance requirements. Instead, the state OCD-DRU waited 30 days then sent out final notice letters to homeowners citing the policy line change of Oct. 5, 2018 version 4.0. The method the state used to communicate this notice of change was received as being cruel to the unsuspecting homeowners. 

A copy of the notice sent to flood victims giving them 30 days to purchase the correct amount of Flood Insurance or be deemed ineligible for the Program is linked here.

Many homeowners were unaware of the HUD policy regarding flood insurance, and the state's documents did not convey the information clearly in the flyer version 3.1. This policy required homeowners to carry the coverage of the full grant amount and program costs at the time the applicant signed for the grant award. Many were told at signing that their FEMA insurance was enough to get them started. 

For one of our neighbors, their FEMA flood insurance policy only covered $30,000 of the $40,000 grant they signed months ago. Our neighbor had so far only received $100 of the total $40,000 grant and was told to increase flood insurance or been deemed ineligible. The homeowner, given such short notice, had to borrow the funds from a family member to purchase a new flood policy. The documents sent to homeowner's implied that they could simply add additional coverage to their FEMA Group policy, but this was found to be 100% incorrect, and the flyer sent out to homeowners was not updated with the correct information.

The following line was added to the Restore Louisiana Homeowners Assistance Manual version 4.0 published Oct. 5, 2018. 

Modified Section 5(a) by adding the following line:
"The full insurable value of the structure will be based upon the Program's final total project cost for the applicant."

The Program (Restore) didn't make it clear to homeowners that they were required to have the full grant award covered (which is the full program costs insured) before they signed the grant closing documents. But, the state OCD-DRU made it very clear that this mistake of not informing homeowners was going to be cleared up by the homeowner within 30 days of the date on the letter or be "deemed ineligible" for program grants. 

The state could have made the announcement via the programs hired Media and Outreach people from Emergent Method LLC, Nick Speyrer and Alyson Gaharan. The state could have used the Program's official Facebook.com RestoreLA_Gov to inform the select few individuals that actually follow the Program online. The hired sub-contractor Emergent Method LLC could have reached out to me, and I would have announced the updated insurance requirement as soon as it was published Oct. 5, 2018. We do have a group of more than 500 members that are very active with sharing information and announcements. Without proper notice to the public and to the homeowners about changes made to the Restore Louisiana Homeowners Assistance Manual, the state is creating an environment that could cause homeowners to fail in their recovery efforts. 

Final Post V of V:

  1. State of Louisiana Announces Pay Up Flood Insurance or Get Out of the RLHP Disaster Program!
  2. Pay Up or Get Out, You have not provided evidence that you are maintaining sufficient flood insurance.
  3. Part III Pay Up or Get Out, Flood Insurance Requirements Homeowners Assistance Program version 3.1
  4. Part IV Pay Up or Get Out, Flood Insurance HUD CDBG-DR Federal Policy, Laws, Rules
  5. OCD-DRU Patrick Forbes accuses flood victim "..creating unnecessary panic and frustration among flood victims"

Ongoing Research "The States Responsibility to Communicate HUD Policy and Requirements to Citizens" will continue in our Research Section. The states OCD-DRU has created a disaster scenario that could lead to homeowners being denied any and all future federal relief.


Comment | Suggestion | Feedback

Share on Facebook
Share on Twitter
Share on LinkedIn
Share on Pinterest
Share on Reddit
TruckAndTools.Com News

Louisiana Community and Technical College System (LCTCS) to expand heavy equipment operator training courses

By Murray Wennerlund published 5-22-2022
Contribute $3.00 | | Print | Tag: Training | Category: 23
Patrick Forbes Director of the Office of Community Development - Disaster Recovery Unit and Chair of the Louisiana Watershed Initiative has announced the Flood Ready Workforce Development Program which provides heavy equipment training funded by HUD CDBG

Continue Reading

Flood Ready Workforce Development Program funded by 2016 flood grants pays for heavy equipment training.

By Murray Wennerlund published 5-19-2022 updated 5-26-2022
Contribute $3.00 | | Print | Tag: Training | Category: 23
Its not clear if you have to pay up front, complete the training then request reimbursement from the OCD-DRU who is using Homeowner grant funds to pay for the future of their coastal project labor pool. In any case, 2,000 isnt much for employment.

Continue Reading

Prohibition on disaster assistance for households above 120 percent AMI for failure to obtain flood insurance

By Murray Wennerlund published 5-18-2022
Contribute $3.00 | | Print | Tag: Flood Insurance | Category: 23
If you are living in a SFHA otherwise known as the 100 year flood zone and are earning more than 120 percent AMI you should be able to afford your flood insurance no matter if you are required to purchase flood insurance or not.

Continue Reading

Restore Louisiana Mobile Home MHU Replacement Policy published 7-17-2019

By Murray Wennerlund published 5-17-2022 updated 5-29-2022
Contribute $3.00 | | Print | Tag: MHU | Category: 23
Louisiana has fought over the replacement costs for mobile homes for years. Reimbursement for the total amount has always been the goal but the state of Louisiana OCD-DRU has done everything to not give enough to replace MHUs for safe housing.

Continue Reading

Monitoring state level disaster recovery programs

By Murray Wennerlund published 1-15-2022
Contribute $3.00 | Print | Tag: Oversight | Category: 23
Citizens are being fleeced each and every disaster of tax dollars allocated to assist in their recovery after a declared disaster. States that go unchecked little or no program oversight cost us millions.

Continue Reading

Disaster Assistance by Louisiana Governors Get a Game Plan using Communications Obscurity to limit assistance

By Murray Wennerlund published 10-4-2021 updated 1-15-2022
Contribute $3.00 | Print | Tag: Obscurity | Category: 23
How Louisiana makes its "Get a Game Plan" nearly impossible for the people living in the state to understand where to get disaster recovery assistance. With every new storm, new websites are created and now they are creating compartmental websites.

Continue Reading

Louisiana Hurricane Ida Supplies from Points of Distribution (PODS) POD Status Log - WebEOC 9.1

By Murray Wennerlund published 9-10-2021
Contribute $3.00 | PDF | Print | Tag: POD | Category: 23
The Louisiana Governors Office of Homeland Security Emergency Preparedness GOSHEP publishes daily a list of all Points of Distribution operating in the state. This list seems to be updated every morning and is linked win this article.

Continue Reading

Louisiana Hurricane Ida 4611-DR-LA

By Murray Wennerlund published 9-7-2021 updated 1-15-2022
Contribute $3.00 | Print | Tag: Declarations | Category: 23
Louisiana Hurricane Ida FEMA 4611-DR-LA , DR-4611 links, research and resources.

Continue Reading

Rental assistance available for those in hardship due to COVID-19

By Murray Wennerlund published 8-22-2021 updated 12-31-2021
Contribute $3.00 | Print | Tag: RentalAssistance | Category: 23
All state and U.S. Territories have a point of contact for rental assistance and housing assistance. These services have been in place for years and have been used by thousands for housing concerns.

Continue Reading

SNAP FORM 38 Statement Regarding Food Lost in a Household Misfortune

By Murray Wennerlund published 2-19-2021 updated 1-15-2022
Contribute $3.00 | | Print | Tag: DSNAP | Category: 23
Did you lose all the food in your refrigerator because of the storm that cause you to lose power for more than 24 hours? Were you told that you do not qualify for SNAP replacement by the state or by anyone else? Lets get your paperwork filed today, now.

Continue Reading